These are my thoughts after watching the first episode of the new documentary named after the 1999 masterpiece. Minor spoilers.
Many of you are probably quite disappointed with the reboot, while others of you are nostalgic and impressed by the "revival". In my opinion, people are overboard on both sides, honestly the greatest on the former.
To begin with, let's consider the cutscenes. In episode 1, 'The Orphan', the story regularly turns to a current expedition instigated by the North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences in the Hell Creek badlands of Montana. While I have seen some complaining about this formatting, I personally don't mind it. It's interesting to see the process of actually unearthing the legend, piece by piece, so long after featured species faded. I was surprised to see the use of the UV-scanner drone technique - something I hadn't heard of prior and plan to seek updates on. I will admit that some cutscene were a little unnecessary and some of the dialog seemed forced.
The story itself was, in general, very exciting. Pacing was spot-on for me, and the ending satisfactory. On the flipside, the "hero-villain" narrative - Clover being the former and T. rex being the latter - was pretty ridiculous and unrealistic. The introduction of Tyrannosaurus could have been more subtle and engaging.
Animal designs were above-average throughout the program. The tyrannosaur looked fairly accurate to my knowledge, with an amazing head design. Other than with the Infernodrakon, no colourations in the episode wowed me. Clover was adorable and fun to follow.
Now, the CGI. Paleo-enthusiasts are whining far too much about this aspect online. Sure, it's not quite Prehistoric Planet or even Life On Our Planet level, but it is decent for a BBC project. It reminds me aesthetically of WWD 2015 and failed to take away significantly from my enjoyment. If anything movements were choppy at times but not insanely so.
Some gripes I have with the episode lie with the animal behaviors. The only shown T. rex individual was such an incompetent hunter - what sort of hunting tactic is just walking up to a prey item that is perfectly capable of harming you? I saw not a scrap of an ambush; the only successful hunts were due to equally idiotic prey behaviors. The Infernodrakon was unbelievably unalert and literally turned down free food snooping around it's nest. Rhino-like goring charges exhibited by the bull Triceratops were a bit unrealistic when its anatomy is considered.
I also feel like the Edmontosaurus group was quite diminutive - but, who knows if small families occasionally lived isolated from herds?
In conclusion, this does not feel like Walking With Dinosaurs. That said, it isn't a terrible documentary. The mysterious and speculative story of an orphan trike was indeed satisfying. As far as dinosaur documentaries go, I'd consider this episode a high 6/10. I'd probably find myself rewatching and enjoying it comparably to Planet Dinosaur.
I hope that the tales improve in subsequent episodes.