For One...

This is not actually entirely accurate... ALSO...

Smilodon Gracilis is 70 - 80 Cm Tall

Thylacosmilus Atrox is 59 - 68 Cm Tall

Thylacosmilus is also 180 - 260 Lbs, well S.Gracilis is 130 - 220 Lbs... Thyla is a full 30 - 50 Pounds heavier then Smilodon, and every pound counts...

ALSO Thylaco still had powerful limbs and its paws weren't quite as stabby like you say, and it was still highly likely a good grappler...

SO AGAIN... Thylacosmilus Atrox can fully handle itself in a fight with S.Gracilis and go head to head with it even in grappling (ALSO Weight > Height) and Gracilis is still gonna have an actual hard time overpowering and subduing Thylaco to get a good bite, well being the shorter and stockier of the two, with longer fangs, Thylaco can easily go for the limbs of Smilodon to weaken it and prohibit its grappling capabilities, and then get its own Good Lethal Bite...

I AM ALSO NOT SAYING THAT EITHER WIN AN SIGNIFICANT PERCENTAGE ABOVE THE OTHER! At the least its a 50/50, but the slight edge goes to Thylaco bc of its size, fangs, and build.

The size comparison I posted is not inaccurate. It’s literally from Wikipedia, the source you gave from the beginning.

Ok... I said it was not entirely accurate, I never said it was inaccurate, BUT, Thylaco and S.Gracilis are overall closer in height then that poster shows.

ANYWAYS - Hope ya guys like Part 20, its gonna be an actual fight between Titans when its comes out Tomorrow or Friday.

I could see this going either way but I'll vote Smilodon gracilis because I can

My favorite image

^same

Ok

So vertically compressed and horizontally stretched that Thylacosmilus almost looks closer in height to Smilodon gracilis than it actually was, for real.

Gracilis at most was only 15+ Cm Taller then Thylaco, that's not a big enough height advantage to truly be significant...

And Don't bring up the poster you used yesterday, its not 100% correct.