Broken Jaw has plot armor

Big Al died after he stubbed his toe(relatable)

Big Al since he has the better coloring

Let's see, Big Al is not a fully grown adult, had lots of injuries, and third reason that I can't think of

Meanwhile Broken Jaw.... has a broken jaw

Big Al

Virgin Big Al: Ow I stubbed my toe.

Chad Broken Jaw: Had his jaw broken by a sauropod at a young age. Still had the guts to take on a Torvosaurus.

Broken Jaw because his goofy ahh intimidation display will scare Big Al away.

Depending on who writes it, I could see either winning.